Judge and Executioner

You have to interrogate three prisoners and decide their fates. Each offer light/darkside choices. An interesting twist is that the "best" way to solve each situation is not necessarily going darkside.

"Best" results
Let the spy live (lightside) recruit her to join the Sith
Force choke the failed Sith, don't give him the honor of a duel
Kill/Torture the other one, do not let him live/do nothing

This doesn't change anything story wise but gets you the most "praise" from your master.

Just remember in making your light and dark side choice that any opposing choice will cancel out the same amount of points from the earning pool.

(Explained)

Letting the assassin live earned you 100 LS points. But then killing Devotek earned you 100 DS points leaving you with 0 LS or DS points.
Then torturing/killing Bregh(sp?) earns you back 100 DS points.
So in total when you go and turn in your quest to Trimmel you've only earned 100 DS points.

The Exp and Reward are the same no matter what you choose to do, so if your only interested in getting DS points over a few extra credits or praise for making the right decisions then kill all three.

BUT remember all your choices and decisions regardless of points DO matter later in the game.

Korriban
- Arm Yourself - Level 3
- Judge and Executioner - Level 4
- Slaying the Beast - Level 6
- A New Master - Level 7
- Sith Arithmetic - Level 8
- The Final Trial - Level 11 [Vette]
- Leaving Korriban - Level 11

Dromund Kaas
- The Flight to Dromund Kaas - Level 9
- The Transporter - Level 10
- Pull the Plug - Level 12
- Laying Waste - Level 14
- An Ancient Answer - Level 16
- Leaving Dromund Kaas - Level 16 - [Spaceship & Start Chapter 1]

Balmorra
- Contact Made - Level 15
- Erase the Past - Level 17
- Silence the Son - Level 18
- To Kill a Legend - Level 19 [Malavai Quinn]

Nar Shaddaa
- Seek Your Contact - Level 21
- Disrupt Negotiations - Level 21
- An Army of One - Level 22
- Distress Call - Level 22
- To Kill a Sith Lord - Level 23
- A Threat Leveled - Level 24

Tatoonie
- Seek Answers - Level 25
- Demon's Blood - Level 26
- Oasis - Level 27
- Guru in the Dunes - Level 28

Alderaan
- Shake Down - Level 28
- Knock Knock - Level 29
- Front Lines - Level 29
- Choke Point - Level 30
- Battle Organa - Level 30
- Deal with Kendoh - Level 31
- The Plan is Working! - Level 32
- The Padawan Exposed - Level 32 [Jaesa Willsaam]
- A Sith Lord's Rise - Level 32 [End Chapter 1]
- Set the Table - Level 32

Taris
- Check in - Level 32
- General Frellka - Level 32
- General Minst - Level 33
- General Durand - Level 34
- General Faraire - Level 35 [Lieutenant Pierce]

Quesh
- Ambush! - Level 36

Hoth
- Debriefing - Level 37
- Rescue Lanklyn - Level 37
- Interrogate the Talz - Level 38
- The Master's Weapon - Level 39
- Jedi Master on Ice - Level 40 [Broonmark]
- Power Play - Level 41
- Fanning the Flames - Level 41 [End Chapter 2]
- Declaration of War - Level 41

Belsavis
- Strong Arm - Level 42
- Locate the Enemy - Level 42
- A Mass of Assassins - Level 43
- Thwart the Rescue - Level 43
- Reallocation - Level 44

Voss
- Request and Audience - Level 44
- The Pain of Healing - Level 45
- Pendant of Bone - Level 46
- The Voice of Darkness - Level 47
- The Transponder Station - Level 48

Correlia
- Protect Vowrawn - Level 47
- Squeeze the Spy - Level 48
- Jedi Spy - Level 49
- Baras's Lair - Level 50
- Retribution - Level 50

I went with the most "evil" choices, killed first two and tortured the third. My master told me I should have let the first one (the assassin) live, but was happy with the other two choices.

Quest rewards: 126 credits, 1430 XP (same as "Best" results, as mentioned by previous poster), 300 dark side points, and Sith Dueling Leathers (med armor chest piece, 34 Armor, ilvl 12, 4 Str, and 4 Endurance.)

I say go with whichever choices you want. Personally, I'd take the extra 100 Dark side points over a measly 21 credits.

Hi Cyvaris... I'm not sure what's the point of this ?

Most "praise" by your master ? But does it give anything special ?

If not... mouhahahah they all deserve to die
;-)